Skip to main content

A History Of The 'Big' Business Of Hip-Hop

Hip-hop music grew from the streets of Harlem and the Bronx into a multi-billion-dollar industry. Dan Charnas chronicles how hip-hop producers and entrepreneurs changed the music industry and pop culture in The Big Payback.




Related Topics

Other segments from the episode on December 9, 2010

Fresh Air with Terry Gross, December 9, 2010: Interview with Dan Charnas; Review of the best books of 2010.


Fresh Air
12:00-13:00 PM
A History Of The 'Big' Business Of Hip-Hop


This is FRESH AIR. I'm Terry Gross.

Everyone who thought that rap music wouldn't last long was proven wrong. My
guest, Dan Charnas, says the phenomenon of hip-hop can't be understood by just
examining the lives of the artists because the culture could not have survived
and thrived without the people who funded, promoted and sold it.

That's why Charnas' new book, "The Big Payback," is a history of the business
of hip-hop. Some of the most influential hip-hop entrepreneurs are also
performers, like Sean Combs, Kanye West and Jay-Z.

Charnas used to work in the hip-hop industry. He started in the mailroom of
Profile Records in the 1980s, which was the home of Run-DMC. He became the
label's rap, A&R and promotion manager and also worked for Rick Rubin as vice
president of A&R and promotion at Def American.

Charnas wrote about hip-hop for the Source magazine and other publications and
is a graduate of the Columbia School of Journalism.

Dan Charnas, welcome to FRESH AIR. You describe in your book how hip-hop went
from street and party music to, you know, to recordings and radio play. And
that story kind of starts with Sugar Hill Records and the track "Rapper's
Delight." What was the importance of that recording?

Mr. DAN CHARNAS (Author, "The Big Payback: The History of the Business of Hip-
Hop"): Well, it was a record that basically was the first of its kind and
auspicious in that even though it was the first of its kind, it became a huge
international hit, even bigger than the record that it actually sampled, which
was "Good Times" by Chic.

Basically, it's a record that created an industry. Nobody thought that the
stuff that was in the streets was even music. It was just stuff that people did
at parties. But Sylvia Robinson, who co-founded Sugar Hill with her husband Joe
Robinson, heard this stuff and had the notion that she could actually turn it
into a record. And she did, and it was extremely successful, due in no small
part to her own production genius.

GROSS: So she actually created the Sugarhill Gang. They were not a pre-existing
trio of rappers. How did she put the group together?

Mr. CHARNAS: That's right. She wanted to, I think, work with Lovebug Starski,
who was the first rapper that she ever heard, but when she didn't hear back
from him, she had her son Joey Jr. basically put together this crew of people
from suburban New Jersey who weren't really tied to the scene. They weren't
known across the river in the Bronx and in Harlem.

And so she had this sort of make-shift audition outside of a pizza parlor in
Inglewood and put these three guys together who had never met each other
before, had the backing track all ready, again a replaying of Chic's hit "Good
Times," and created this record in a matter of minutes.

GROSS: So let's hear the opening of "Rapper's Delight." Tell us what you think
really stood out when this came out in - was it '78, '79?

Mr. CHARNAS: '79, summer of - actually late summer of '79, I believe September
of '79.

GROSS: So what made this stand out when it was...

Mr. CHARNAS: Well, the defining line for me in that opening is: What you hear
is not a test. I'm rapping to the beat. And me, the crew and my friends are
going to try to move your feet.

What he's saying is that what you're about to hear, these guys talking on top
of this music, is something new and something that you've never heard before.
And it occurs to me that he felt that he had to try to explain what this new
phenomenon was.

And, of course, this is something that people had to explain not only in this
first record but in record after record after record until the mainstream
establishment finally got that this was something that was really important.

GROSS: OK, so here's "Rapper's Delight" by the Sugarhill Gang, recorded in

(Soundbite of song, "Rapper's Delight")

THE SUGARHILL GANG (Rap Group): (Rapping) I said hip, hop, the hippie the
hippie, do the hip, hip, hop, and you don't stop, the rocket to the bang, bang,
boogie, say up jumped the boogie to the rhythm of the boogie beat.

Now what you hear is not a test. I'm rapping to the beat. And me, the groove,
and my friends are going to try to move your feet. See I am Wonder Mike, and
I'd like to say hello to the black, to the white, the red, and the brown, the
purple and yellow. But first I got to bang, bang the boogie to the boogie, say
up jump the boogie to the bang, bang boogie. Let's rock, you don't stop. Rock
the riddle that will make your body rock. Well so far you've heard my voice,
but I brought...

GROSS: So that's the first real rap record that made it onto radio that sold,
and boy did it sell.

Mr. CHARNAS: That's right.

GROSS: And it's a big part of the story in the new book "The Big Payback: The
History of the Business of Hip-Hop" by my guest Dan Charnas.

So - now one of the things about this record that I think infuriated a lot of
people in the hip-hop world was that one of the rhymes in this was actually
taken from a different rapper. Would you tell the story?

Mr. CHARNAS: Well, one of the guys in the group, Big Bang Hank, he was, I guess
you could call him either a roadie or a manager for the Cold Crush Brothers,
who were a very well-known and very well-respected crew in the Bronx, who had
no records.

And, I mean, there weren't any rap records at the time. So when Ms. Rob, Ms.
Robinson, you know, told Big Bang Hank she wanted to make this record, he went
back over to Grandmaster Caz, who was on the lyricists in the Cold Crush
Brothers, and said: Do you mind if I borrow a few of your rhymes?

And Caz basically threw his lyric book at Hank and said, here, use whatever you
want. Because the notion of a rap record was so ridiculous to everybody. Who
thought that it would amount to anything, especially Hank, who wasn't an MC at

GROSS: So should we hear that part of the record, where he takes Casanova's

Mr. CHARNAS: Sure.


Mr. CHARNAS: And he says his name.

GROSS: He acts like he's Casanova?

Mr. CHARNAS: He says: I'm a C-A-S-N-O-V-A. And it was literally his rhyme. He
didn't even bother to change, you know, change the name.

GROSS: OK, here it is.

(Soundbite of song, "Rapper's Delight")

THE SUGARHILL GANG: (Rapping) Check it out. I'm the C-A-S-N, the O-V-A, and the
rest is F-L-Y. You see, I go by the code of the doctor of the mix, and these
reasons I'll tell you why. You see, I'm six-foot-one and I'm tons of fun, and I
dress to a T. You see, I got more clothes than Muhammad Ali, and I dress so
viciously. I got bodyguards, I got two big cars...

GROSS: OK, that's another part of "Rapper's Delight" by the Sugarhill Gang. And
my guest, Dan Charnas, is the author of the new book, "The Big Payback: The
History of the Business of Hip-Hop."

OK, so the Robinsons with their record label, Sugar Hill Records, brought rap
music to the radio, to the record store. But what did the artists who recorded
for the record label think of the label and of the two people who ran it?

Mr. CHARNAS: I think that very quickly, people felt taken advantage of by the
Robinsons. You know, the Robinsons operated much like a lot of operators in the
indie record world, you know, operating on kind of a shoestring budget, betting
their own money on the possibility of success and really holding on to cash and
not necessarily giving the kind of accountings that a more corporate company

I think that they were seen as greedy, seen as interlopers and very quickly got
a very bad reputation in the quote-unquote real hip-hop world.

GROSS: Did the performers get royalties on their record sales?

Mr. CHARNAS: I don't believe that they did. I think they had to ask for
everything they got after their initial advance, if they got an advance at all.
And I think that according to the research and the anecdotes that I've
collected, I think that for the most part, artists had to beg for any moneys
that they got, and it was given grudgingly.

GROSS: Did they take - did the Robinsons take songwriting credits or...

Mr. CHARNAS: They did, and the most famous of those credits were for "Rapper's
Delight," in which the musical track was lifted from Nile Rodgers and Bernard
Edwards, who wrote the original song "Good Times," and those two writers had to
sue and eventually won credit for that song.

GROSS: So how long did Sugar Hill's prominence last in the hip-hop world?

Mr. CHARNAS: Well, Sugar Hill basically had kind of a lock on the business in
the early 1980s, which I believe they kind of frittered away over the years,
partly because of the bad reputation that they developed for paying artists and
partly, I think, hubris.

There's a story in the book of a young concert promoter from down south named
Cedric Walker(ph). And Cedric has this idea that he, he's going to create this
sort of three-ring circus of hip-hop that includes DJ'ing and MC'ing and break

And he wants to get Sylvia Robinson excited about this concept. So he flies on
his own dime to New York, he goes to Sugar Hill's offices, he meets with Sylvia
Robinson. And she literally curses him out and throws him out of the office,
saying: Why do I need you for? I was the first person to put a rap act on tour.

Cedric Walker walks out of this meeting, he goes back across the river, and his
Plan B is to talk to this minor, lesser artist-manager by the name of Russell
Simmons, who has some budding rap acts like Houdini and Run-DMC. And so it's
Russell Simmons who gets to make this deal with Ricky Walker, and that tour
idea eventually becomes the Fresh Fest, which was the first successful national
rap tour and in a way symbolizes how Sylvia Robinson and Joe Robinson and Sugar
Hill were eclipsed by people like Russell Simmons.

GROSS: My guest is Dan Charnas, author of the book "The Big Payback: The
History of the Business of Hip-Hop." We'll talk more after a break. This is

(Soundbite of music)

GROSS: Let's get back to our interview with Dan Charnas about his new book "The
Big Payback: The History of the Business of Hip-Hop."

You say if you heard a rap record on the radio in 1984, Russell Simmons had
something to do with it. Some examples?

Mr. CHARNAS: That's right. Russell Simmons obviously was the manager and
producer of Run-DMC, Run of Run-DMC, is his brother Joe. He was the manager of
Houdini, another successful rap act on Jive Records. And Curtis Blow, another -
was the first rapper signed to a major label. That was Russ' first client.

So most of the stuff that you heard on radio that was popular, that was
Russell. Russell had basically made himself into the first person who cared to
develop rap artists from the management side.

GROSS: How is that different, developing them from the management side, from
what Sugar Hill had done?

Mr. CHARNAS: I think Sugar Hill basically was - I think they saw themselves as
riding out a fad. I don't think that they had any particular belief that this
was a powerful culture that had staying power.

I mean, we had just come off of the disco era, which, you know, turned out to
be very, very short-lived. And I'm sure that a lot of people, including Sylvia
and Joe Robinson, thought that the same would happen to this rap stuff.

The difference was that Russell Simmons actually did not like the records that
Sugar Hill was turning out because they didn't sound to him like the hip-hop
that lived in the streets and in the parks and in the clubs, which was very
raw, very beat-oriented and didn't sound like disco at all.

And so Russell Simmons' key innovation, when he made Run-DMC's first record,
was to basically order his producer-partner Larry Smith to take out all the
music - I just want to hear a beat. So it's just two guys rocking over a beat
box with some DJ scratching in between. That was unheard of, and a record like
that had never been done. That, I think, really changed the game musically and
is a great sort of separation point or turning point between the Sugar Hill era
and the era that followed.

GROSS: And that first record that Russell Simmons produced for Run-DMC was
"It's Like That." So why don't we hear it?

Mr. CHARNAS: Indeed.

GROSS: Is there anything else you want us to listen for?

Mr. CHARNAS: Well, "It's Like That," I would just say that "Sucker M.C.'s"
actually was the B-side for that, which was even more radical in many ways than
"It's Like That" because "Sucker M.C.'s" was literally - "It's Like That" had
these little keyboard stabs in it, and "Sucker M.C.'s" had basically nothing in
it but that beat and scratching. Like, that was one of the first times that you
actually heard scratching on a record used for percussive effect.

GROSS: Should we hear that instead?

Mr. CHARNAS: I think that'd be great.


Mr. CHARNAS: I love that record.

GROSS: Let's hear it.

(Soundbite of song, "Sucker M.C.'s")

RUN-DMC (Rap Group): (Rapping) Years ago, a friend of mine asked me to say some
MC rhymes. So I said this rhyme I'm about to say. The rhyme was def and then it
went this way: Took a test to become an MC and Orange Krush became amazed at
me. So Larry put me inside his Cadillac. The chauffeur drove off and we never
came back.

Dave cut the record down to the bone, and now they got me rocking on the
microphone. And then we talking' autograph, and here's the laugh, champagne,
caviar, and bubble bath. But see ah, ah that's the life, ah that I lead, and
you sucker MC's is who I please.

So take that and move back, catch a heart attack because there's nothin' in the
world, that Run'll ever lack. I cold chill at a party in a b-boy stance, and
rock on the mic and make the girls wanna dance, fly like a dove that come from
up above. I'm rocking' on the mic and you can call me Run-Love.

GROSS: That's Run-DMC, and my guest is Dan Charnas, author of the book "The Big
Payback: The History of the Business of Hip-Hop."

So, you know, you were talking about how one of the things Russell Simmons
wanted to do and succeeded in doing was stripping away the music and the disco
from hip-hop recordings and making it more like it sounded at parties and on
the street and reducing it to, like, the beat and scratching.

And you talk about how he did similar things with his sense of what hip-hop
performers should be wearing.

Mr. CHARNAS: Wow, yeah, absolutely. Russell also felt that hip-hop should sound
like itself. It should also look like itself. And in many ways, he stripped
hip-hop of its, I guess you could call it, disco artifice, show-biz artifice.

I think a lot of earlier hip-hop performers from the Bronx, they dressed up in
shiny suits and go-go boots and cowboy fringes and other kinds of things that
were really fantastical, whereas Run-DMC, they were dressed in, you know, sweat
suits, stuff that they might wear on the streets.

Now, you know, it was a stylized version of what kids were wearing, but
nevertheless, it was something that was more authentic to what hip-hop was and
ironic because that hip-hop, that authenticity came from Queens, which was
considered the suburbs, not from the Bronx or Harlem.

GROSS: Though Queens had become pretty urban.

(Soundbite of laughter)

Mr. CHARNAS: That's correct, that's correct. But to the folks in the Bronx,
that was the country.

GROSS: OK, fair enough. So how did Russell Simmons hook up with Rick Rubin and
form their partnership with Def Jam Records?

Mr. CHARNAS: Well, Rick Rubin was a college student, I think a junior at the
time at NYU, who heard "Sucker M.C.'s" and "It's Like That" by Run-DMC and was
inspired to make his own record because he had the same thought.

He had only heard rap on records, but when he finally moved into the city as a
young freshman and saw this stuff as it played out in the clubs, he said, this
stuff is so much better live. Why can't we make a record that sounds like hip-
hop does live, a DJ scratching, MCs over beats?

And so he created a song called "It's Yours." And the irony was he wanted to
make it with a group called the Treacherous Three, who were signed to Sugar
Hill. Because they had exclusivity with Sugar Hill, he had to make it with the
brother of one of the people from the Treacherous Three, who was T La Rock.

Russell Simmons hears this record and goes bonkers. He loves it, and he wants
to know who did the record. And when he finally meets this person who did the
record, he doesn't believe that this white, Jewish college student actually
made that record because, he says, it's the blackest record I've ever heard.

GROSS: So let's hear that track that you're talking about that Rick Rubin
produces and Russell Simmons loves, "It's Yours."

(Soundbite of song, "It's Yours")

T LA ROCK (Rapper): (Rapping) Commentating, illustrating, description giving,
adjective expert. Analyze a song by the musical mystic and people love the
universe. It is yours. It's yours. Do you like it? Do you want it? And if you
had it, would you pawn it? Well, it's yours.

Taking a record that's already made with the help of the mix boys, using the
cross fade. Rhythm...

GROSS: That's "It's Yours" by T La Rock, and my guest is Dan Charnas, author of
the new book "The Big Payback: The History of the Business of Hip-Hop."

So in some ways, they're a very unlikely combination, but they get together.
And what roles did they each play in the new partnership of Def Jam Records?

Mr. CHARNAS: I think that Rick was the studio rat. He was the guy who was going
to really be a hands-on producer and visionary for the records themselves. He
was a great A&R man. He had an ear for talent.

Russell Simmons, his strong suit was promotion. Russell talked and talked and
talked until people listened to him, and he talked some more until he convinced
them of what he wanted them to do. And he talked some more until they became
his friends and wanted to do anything they could for him.

And that was - that combination was the success behind the record company that
they partnered on, which was called Def Jam, which basically became the first –
rather, it wasn't the first, but it was the successor to Sugar Hill as far as
being the dominant rap brand but ended up having tremendous staying power over
the years.

GROSS: And it was a rap label that was headed by people who were deep into rap.
It just wasn't another way of keeping a label alive or of making money. They
loved this. This was their lives.

Mr. CHARNAS: That's the most important point, too. It was a label made by and
for rap fans.

GROSS: So you describe Def Jam as turning nine minute toasts, you know, like
the early hip-hop recordings, to three-minute songs with classic pop structure:
verse, bridge, chorus. So what was the force responsible for making this into a
more pop form? Was that Rick Rubin, do you think?

Mr. CHARNAS: I think that, you know, it's equal parts Rick and the intelligence
of the artists with whom he worked. You know, these were people who grew up on
pop music themselves and perhaps saw themselves - had a bit more aspiration
than the folks who just wanted to rhyme and rhyme and rhyme. So I think it was
definitely a collaboration.

But what came out of it was a completely new vision for what hip-hop could be.
And I think it was that work that really solidified the idea in many fans of
this - in the minds of many fans of this music that hip-hop could be the next
rock 'n' roll.

GROSS: Dan Charnas will be back in the second half of the show. His new book is
called "The Big Payback: The History of the Business of Hip-Hop." I'm Terry
Gross, and this is FRESH AIR.

(Soundbite of music)


This is FRESH AIR. I'm Terry Gross back with Dan Charnas, the author of the new
book "The Big Payback," about the history of the business of hip-hop and the
people who funded, promoted, and sold the music. Charnas is a journalist who's
covered hip-hop and used to work in the industry. He was vice president of A&R
and promotion at Rick Rubin's Def American.

When we left off, we were talking about the label that Rick Rubin and Russell
Simmons used to run together, Def Jam Records.

So there is a third person that enters the partnership with Russell Simmons and
Rick Rubin and that's Lyor Cohen and what's his role in their business?

Mr. CHARNAS: Lyor Cohen is a concert promoter in Los Angeles who basically,
according to Russell, just shows up on his doorstep one day saying, I want to
come work for you. Although, Lyor has a different story. He says that Russell
offered him a piece of the company.

But Lyor quickly begins to earn Russell's trust on the management side, which
is Rush Artist Management, which is Russell's management company, which is the
flipside to the record company, Def Jam. And Lyor quickly ends up being able to
make a lot of money for Russell on the management side. He not only shepherded
Run-DMC as a tour manager through Europe and basically created some deals
whereby Russell could leave Cedric Walker behind them to Def Jam tours instead
of the Fresh Fest tours, but he also arranged one of the first, if not the
first, merchandising deals for rap artists with Winterland Company and the
first endorsement deal with Adidas for Run-DMC.

But Lyor is primarily a businessman and Rick Rubin is primarily an artist, so
when - where they came into conflict was in issues over Def Jam artists who
were also Rush clients, like Run-DMC and the Beastie Boys. And very quickly it
devolves into a situation where the two of them are arguing a lot and

GROSS: About what? What were their differences?

Mr. CHARNAS: Well, one example in the book is how Rick Rubin wanted the
Beasties to do a movie but he wanted to be the one to control how it was rolled
out because he didn't trust Hollywood to do anything but make a mockery of the
Beastie Boys. Whereas, Lyor Cohen just charged ahead and started making, you
know, arranging meetings for the Beastie Boys out in Los Angeles, which Rick
quickly found out about and basically said if they take any deal that I'm not a
part of or I'm not in control of, I will not allow the Beasties to use their
own music or perform in this movie.

So that was a big bone of contention between Rick and the group, between Rick
and Lyor, and Russell was sort of caught in the middle of it and at one point
he turns to Bill Adler, the publicist for Rush and laments, my Jews are

(Soundbite of laughter)

GROSS: So who won the fight?

Mr. CHARNAS: I think that Rick basically just surrendered. I don't think that
he wanted to fight Lyor Cohen or fight Russell, because Russell and Rick also
had very differing musical tastes and I don't think that Rick liked any of the
things that Russell was bringing to the label. So at a restaurant nearby Def
Jam's offices, the Noho Star, Rick takes Russell out and says, listen, I want
to remain friends but I think the only way to do it is if we are not working
together anymore. So do you want to leave the company and leave it to me? And
Russell says no. And Rick says, OK, I guess I'll leave.

And he left. He went to California and left the whole company behind and left
the lawyers for years and years to work out the disengagement or divorce
agreement between the two of them.

GROSS: And then he leaves hip-hop, too, and instead produces heavy metal and
eventually ends up doing, like, you know, Johnny Cash's stripped-down
recordings, that great American music series. And when Rick Rubin leaves hip-
hop, you quote him as having said, and I'm paraphrasing here, that hip-hop
isn't any longer about art, it's about getting paid.

Mr. CHARNAS: That right. That's what he told me when I started to work for him
too, that he felt that one of the reasons he left hip-hop - he said hip-hop
didn't - I'm not leaving hip-hop, hip-hop left me.

GROSS: Did you share his feelings, though?

Mr. CHARNAS: I didn't because I think that there was a lot about hip-hop that
Rick didn't understand at the time. He didn't understand political hip-hop. He
didn't understand the new sort of digitally sampled hip-hop that relied a lot
on the music of James Brown, which was very soulful and very funky and not very
- didn't feel very rock oriented and I think Rick liked the rock aesthetic in

GROSS: If you're just joining us, my guest is Dan Charnas, the author of the
new book "The Big Payback: The History of the Business of Hip-Hop."

Now you write a little bit about the RZA of the Wu-Tang Clan.

Mr. CHARNAS: Mm-hmm.

GROSS: Before we go any further, choose one of your favorite records by the RZA
or by the Wu-Tang Clan and we'll play it.

Mr. CHARNAS: I think the one we've got to listen to is "Protect Ya Neck"
because that was the record that they did on their own. And in response to -
the record was a response to basically RZA and his cousin the GZA being dropped
off of two Time Warner owned labels and having to pick up the pieces themselves
and that's a big story in "The Big Payback."

GROSS: OK. So here's "Protect Ya Neck."

(Soundbite of song, "Protect Ya Neck")

WU-TANG GANG (Hip-hop group): (Rapping) So what's up man? Cooling man.
Chilling, chilling? Yo, you know I had to call, you know why right? Why?
Because, yo, I never ever call and ask, you to play something right? Yeah. You
know what I wanna hear right? What you wanna hear? I wanna hear that Wu-Tang
joint. Wu-Tang again? Ah yeah, again and again.

(Soundbite of fighting)

Wu-Tang Clan coming at you, protect your neck kid, so set it off the Inspector
Deck. Watch your step kid. Watch your step kid. Watch your step kid. Watch your
step kid. Watch your step kid. Watch your step kid.

Smoke on the mic like smoking Joe Frazier. The hell raiser, raised hell with
the flavor. Terrorize the jam like troops in Pakistan. Swinging through your
town like your neighborhood Spiderman. So, tick tock and keep ticking. While I
get you flipping off the (bleep) I'm kicking. The Lone Ranger, code red,
danger. Deep in the dark with the art to rip charts apart. The vandal, too hot
to handle your battle. You're saying "Goodbye" like Tevin Campbell. Roughneck,
Inspector Deck's on the set. The rebel. I make more noise than heavy metal.

The way I make the crowd go wild, sit back relax won't smile. Ray got it going
on, pal, call me the rap assassinator. Rhymes rugged and built like
Schwarzenegger. And I'm going to get mad deep like a...

GROSS: So that's the Wu-Tang Gang, "Protect Ya Neck." And how did you think
that the RZA to the Wu-Tang Clan changed the business model of hip-hop?

Mr. CHARNAS: I love his story. Essentially, he and his cousin were signed to
record labels owned by Time Warner and dropped after their first records were
not successful. And what RZA did, whether consciously or unconsciously, is
basically claimed his power. He said that I'm going to create a super group out
of all of these folks, the tempest-tossed of the record business, if you will.

And instead of trying to get a deal with a label just like I have and just like
every rapper wants, I'm going to start my own thing. And instead of making a
deal with one label, I'm going to deal with them all and not only deal with
them all but deal with them as a sovereign.

So what he does is he asks labels, in order to deal with the Wu-Tang Clan,
which is a huge, sprawling eight to nine member group, he says you have - in
order to deal with my group, you have to allow me to sign the individual
members of this group to their own separate deals for solo deals. And this was
unheard of in the record business. Record contracts have this clause in them
call the leaving member clause which entitles anybody who invests in a group,
any label who invests in a group to, if that group should break up, that label
is entitled to retain the rights to record the individual members. And usually
at a lesser rate.

But because this record was so hot in the streets, this one single, "Protect Ya
Neck," RZA was able to actually get RCA to waive the leaving member clause of
the Wu-Tang Clan's contract. So he was able to sign Method Man to Def Jam and
he was able to sign Ol' Dirty Bastard to Elektra and GZA to Geffen Records. And
within five years, all of the six major labels at the time had a stake in the
success of the Wu-Tang Clan.

And that's huge because what it is, it's the turnabout of the relationship
between the artist and the record label. Instead of artists seeking out the
opportunity to be branded by Columbia Records or Elektra Records, it's Elektra
Records and Colombia that are seeking out, they want to be branded by the
market, the W. And that's one of the untold stories of the success of the Wu-
Tang Clan.

GROSS: My guest is Dan Charnas, author of the new book "The Big Payback: The
History of the Business of Hip-Hop."

We'll talk more after a break. This is FRESH AIR.

(Soundbite of music)

GROSS: Let's get back to our interview with Dan Charnas, about his new book
"The Big Payback: The History of the Business of Hip-Hop."

So let's jump ahead to Jay-Z and where you see him as fitting into the business
of hip-hop.

Mr. CHARNAS: Well, when you talk about Jay-Z, it's important not to leave out
the contributions of his first partner, Damon Dash. Jay-Z and Damon Dash were
in many ways a sort of a perfect yin yang partnership that Rick Rubin and
Russell Simmons were for Def Jam.

You know, Jay was quiet, deliberate, an artist and concerned with making the
music and the lyrics the best they could be. He was concerned with image as
well. Damon Dash was loud and brash and insistent and entitled. And one of the
great stories from their partnership is just after Jay-Z has his first few hit
records, Damon Dash goes to a clothing company called Iceberg, Iceberg Jeans,
and he says we'd like to get an endorsement deal. And Iceberg says well, you
know, we're really not interested in Jay-Z, not the kind of person that we want
representing our brand. And Damon says oh, really? OK. Fine. I'm going to start
my own clothing company. I'm going to put you guys out of business.

And that is the inception of Rocawear, which becomes Damon Dash and Jay-Z's
clothing company and essentially a much more valuable company then Roc-A-Fella,
their record label, ever was. And Rocawear was largely Dam's baby. And when Jay
and Dam began to quarrel in the mid-2000s, Dam was eventually forced out of
that partnership. But that clothing company, Rocawear, became Jay-Z's
retirement plan.

GROSS: Not the record company but the clothing company.

Mr. CHARNAS: That's right, Rocawear. Mm-hmm.

GROSS: So where else does Jay-Z fit in businesswise?

Mr. CHARNAS: Well, I think after sort of Dam set the basis for Jay, I think Jay
sort of took the, you know, took the ball and kept running with it.
Essentially, the Roc-A-Fella ethos was that hip-hop can be everything to its
fans. It's not just music, it's not just entertainment even, but it can be the
clothes that they wear, it can be the language that they speak, it could be the
books that they read, it can be even the money that they spend, right, because
Russell Simmons eventually does the RushCard, right, the Visa card for the hip-
hop generation.

So I think Jay really is a product of that and acts according to that ethos. So
he ends up diversifying into nightclubs and owning part of a sports team and a
cosmetic line and then his landmark deal with Live Nation, a joint venture deal
with Live Nation for most of his entertainment products.

GROSS: You know, I've always wondered, there's a number of people in the hip-
hop recording industry who, you know, some of whom are performers who have
become so big as entrepreneurs. And I think more so than in any other kind of
music this has been a phenomenon of hip-hop and I'll include Russell Simmons,
Sean Combs, Jay-Z, and I'm wondering if you've given any thought to why the
entrepreneurial thing is so big in the hip-hop world?

Mr. CHARNAS: Sure. Because when you're shut out, you have to create your own
institutions. So if you're shut out of the discos, you go out into the streets
and the parks and you create your own thing, and if you're shut out of the
major labels you create your own independent labels. And if you're shut out of
the clothing companies, then you create your own clothing companies.

I think one of the great contributions of hip-hop to America is the fostering
of this entrepreneurial ethos. And along with that, a sense of self-worth, a
sense that, you know, I have leverage, that what I produce is worth something
and I'm not going to settle for less. And that's a theme that you see over and
over and over in hip-hop but really started to come to fruition with the Wu-
Tang Clan, with Damon Dash and Jay-Z and Roc-A-Fella and Rocawear.

GROSS: So you have hip-hop basically developing its own business model and its
own kind of industry, because they were shut out of the previously existing
parts of the record world and radio and discos and so on. But eventually, like,
the people in hip-hop start fighting with each other...

Mr. CHARNAS: Yeah.

GROSS: ...and there's feuds, there's shootings, and it gets really ugly at


GROSS: And you've worked in the hip-hop world, you know, in the business, in
the A&R end, and I'm wondering why you think it got to that point.

Mr. CHARNAS: Well, I would actually hearken back to something that Jay-Z said
when you interviewed him on FRESH AIR. He said that, you know, just because I
sign this recording contract and I'm now in this world doesn't mean I'm leaving
the world that I just left behind automatically. I think that a lot of folks
came from a very hardscrabble existence. And because of that, you know, there
were all these tensions and sort of the quick resorting to violence that you
have out in the streets. I think it took folks like Sean Combs and Shawn Jay-Z
Carter a while before they realized that, you know, they had lawyers to deal
with their problems. They didn't have to use their fists or weapons.

GROSS: You wrote your thesis on musical apartheid in America. Was this a
masters thesis or?

Mr. CHARNAS: It was my senior thesis at Boston University.

GROSS: OK. So do you see hip-hop as a force that has racially brought young
people more together or that has been more divisive?

Mr. CHARNAS: Absolutely. I mean I wrote that thesis in 19...

GROSS: Wait, absolutely which?

(Soundbite of laughter)

Mr. CHARNAS: Oh, sorry. Absolutely, yes, it has brought America together in
terms of race and ethnicity as never before. It's hugely important.

When I wrote that thesis in 1989, one of the things I said at the end of the
thesis was that hip-hop has the potential to end this process of what I called
ambivalence. White America's relationship to black culture over the course of
400 years was sort of a simultaneous attraction and repulsion and that that
repulsion was slow, and that sort of racist impulse was slowly being overcome
by the attraction. And you could see it in the jazz movement of the early 20th
century and then in rock 'n' roll and rhythm and blues in the 1950s and 1960s,
which in many ways set the foundation for the civil rights movement and for
white support of it, right?

What hip-hop did in the 1980s and 1990s as it became mainstreamed was, I think,
prep a new generation for this multicultural meritocracy, for a nation in which
we meet each other as cultural equals, as intellectual equals. And, more
importantly, not have to be exactly like each other in order to meet each other
that way.

And in no small way, I think hip-hop contributed to a young generation of white
kids being able to vote for somebody like Barack Obama, and also prepared a
generation of black kids to take the reins of power, through entrepreneurship,
through politics, just through the use of their voice and the use of their pen.

GROSS: Well, Dan Charnas, thanks so much for talking with us.

Mr. CHARNAS: Thank you for having me.

GROSS: Dan Charnas is the author of the new book "The Big Payback: The History
of the Business of Hip-Hop." You can read a chapter and find links to FRESH AIR
interviews with Jay-Z, Rick Rubin, Russell Simmons and Run-DMC's Darryl
McDaniels on our website,

Here's Jay-Z with a very successful track from an album released on Jay-Z's own

(Soundbite of song, "Empire State of Mind")

JAY-Z (Musician): (Rapping) Yeah. Yeah, I'm up at Brooklyn. Now I'm down in
Tribeca, right next to De Niro, but I'll be hood forever. I'm the new Sinatra
and since I made it here, I can make it anywhere, yeah, they love me
everywhere. I used to cop in Harlem. All of my Dominicanos, right there up on
Broadway, brought me back to that McDonalds, took it to my stash spot, 560
State Street, catch me in the kitchen like a Simmons whipping pastry. Cruising
down 8th Street, off white Lexus, driving so slow but BK is from Texas. Me, I'm
up at Bed-Sty, home of that boy Biggie. Now I live on billboard, And I brought
my boys with me. Say what up to Ty Treasury. Still sipping Malta. Sitting
courtside Knicks and Nets give me high fives. I'm spiked out, I can trip a
referee, tell by my attitude that I most definitely from.

Ms. ALICIA KEYS (Musician): (Singing) In New York, concrete jungle where dreams
are made of, there's nothing you can't do. Now you're in New York...

GROSS: Looking for good books to give as gifts or to read yourself? Coming up,
our book critic Maureen Corrigan talks about her favorite books of the year.

This is FRESH AIR.
Fresh Air
12:00-13:00 PM
Maureen Corrigan's Favorite Books Of 2010


Our book critic Maureen Corrigan has a wish for this holiday season: that
everyone read a terrific book, and she has some to recommend. She says she
doesn't care whether you read the books on her 2010 best-books-of-the-year
list, electronically or the old-fashioned way.

MAUREEN CORRIGAN: Sometimes there is justice in the world. That was my first
thought when I heard that Patti Smith had won the National Book Award this fall
for her glorious memoir "Just Kids" - which has just come out in
paperback. Smith wrote the book to honor Robert Mapplethorpe, her youthful
partner in love, art, and ambition; but "Just Kids" is also a celebration of
the frayed beauty of New York City in its so-called years of decline - the late
1960s into the '70s.

Early in her memoir, Smith likens herself to the iconic Audrey Hepburn, a young
girl full of pure yearning. Smith says that she and the more brooding
Mapplethorpe were a curious mix of "Funny Face" and "Faust."

Another standout work of nonfiction this year also explores a famous
relationship that defied convention: Hazel Rowley's biography of the marriage
of Franklin and Eleanor Roosevelt, called simply "Franklin and Eleanor." Rowley
charts the evolution of the Roosevelt union from a standard-issue, high-society
alliance to something we don't even have a label for - maybe semi-open marriage
comes closest.

Speaking of conformity and rebellion, Rebecca Traister's so-very-smart and
lively book about the 2008 presidential campaign called "Big Girls Don't Cry"
teases out how our reigning cultural narratives about femininity and playing
nice came to wield so much power during the campaign and, finally, in the
voting booth.

For all its daring allure, early 20th century American detective fiction pretty
much played by the rules when it came to the standard-issue look of its
detective heroes: Same Spade and company were white straight males who were
quick to pull the trigger on any characters who were different. One enormously
popular detective hero however who smashed the stereotype was Charlie Chan, the
subject of a fascinating mish-mosh of a book also called "Charlie Chan," by
Chinese born scholar Yunte Huang.

In the late 19th century, ordinary people - mill girls, garment workers and
miners - embraced the revolutionary idea that by joining together they might
better their lives. Philip Dray's spectacular narrative history of the American
labor movement called "There Is Power in a Union" reads like a novel, filled
with dramatic acts of barbarism and bravery.

This nonfiction best-of-the-year list has turned out to be composed of stories
and people who refused to play by the rules, so I'll end it with two other out-
of-the-box mentions: first, Laura Hillenbrand's "Unbroken," the unforgettable
and, yes, inspirational World War II tale of Louis Zamperini, Olympic athlete
and prisoner of war. Zamperini's story puts to shame all of us these days who
use the word survivor casually.

Second, two books by Gabrielle Burton, a writer now in her 70s, who's near
near-lifelong obsession with Tamsen Donner, the wife of the leader of the
notorious Donner Party inspired her to write a fabulous on-the-road feminist
memoir called "Searching for Tamsen Donner," as well as an evocative recreation
of Tamsen's lost journal called "Impatient With Desire."

Since we're on to fiction now, here are my top picks: certainly, Jonathan
Franzen's "Freedom," a novel about a marriage, deserved all of its applause
despite the literary spitball fight over Franzen's demi-god status.

My personal favorite novel of the year was Lionel Shriver's "So Much for That,"
a moving black comedy about the emotional and financial cost of health care in

I also admired David Mitchell's beautiful novel "The Thousand Autumns of Jacob
de Zoet" which traces the life of its title character who starts working in
1799 on a small European outpost in the harbor of Nagasaki, Japan.

Finally, Gary Shteyngart's novel "Super Sad True Love Story" moves at warp
speed, telling a dystopian but comic story about a future where books are
derided as objects that smell like wet socks.

I can never close out a literary year without giving a nod to mystery fiction.
The late Stieg Larsson's last Lisbeth Salander novel, "The Girl Who Kicked the
Hornets' Nest," deservedly overpowered all. But this was the year I also
belatedly discovered suspense writer Tana French. French's police procedurals
about the Dublin murder squad, including this year's "Faithful Place," are
brilliantly dark and moody.

I want to end by doffing my hat not to a book but to an independent bookseller
and small press publisher. David Thompson was known throughout the mystery
world. He died suddenly this year at 38. David introduced me to the wonders
noir writers like Reed Farrel Coleman, Daniel Woodrell and Martin Limon. His
legacy is a reminder to all of us who love books that, as someone once said
about the lake critic Irving Howe, enthusiasm is not the enemy of the

GROSS: Maureen Corrigan teaches literature at Georgetown University. You can
find links to all the books on her best-of-the-year list, along with links to
excerpts of those books and Maureen's original reviews of some of those books
on our website,

(Soundbite of music)

GROSS: I'm Terry Gross.

Transcripts are created on a rush deadline, and accuracy and availability may vary. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Please be aware that the authoritative record of Fresh Air interviews and reviews are the audio recordings of each segment.

You May Also like

Did you know you can create a shareable playlist?


Recently on Fresh Air Available to Play on NPR


Daughter of Warhol star looks back on a bohemian childhood in the Chelsea Hotel

Alexandra Auder's mother, Viva, was one of Andy Warhol's muses. Growing up in Warhol's orbit meant Auder's childhood was an unusual one. For several years, Viva, Auder and Auder's younger half-sister, Gaby Hoffmann, lived in the Chelsea Hotel in Manhattan. It was was famous for having been home to Leonard Cohen, Dylan Thomas, Virgil Thomson, and Bob Dylan, among others.


This fake 'Jury Duty' really put James Marsden's improv chops on trial

In the series Jury Duty, a solar contractor named Ronald Gladden has agreed to participate in what he believes is a documentary about the experience of being a juror--but what Ronald doesn't know is that the whole thing is fake.

There are more than 22,000 Fresh Air segments.

Let us help you find exactly what you want to hear.
Just play me something
Your Queue

Would you like to make a playlist based on your queue?

Generate & Share View/Edit Your Queue