Skip to main content

'Gone Girl': A Gripping Film That's More Fun Than The Book.

Based on a screenplay by author Gillian Flynn, the movie is sensationally effective. It's made like a classic noir — evenly paced, with an elegance that in context is deeply perverse.


Other segments from the episode on October 3, 2014

Fresh Air with Terry Gross, October 3, 2014: Interview with Jeff Guinn; Review of the season four premiere of "Homeland"; Review of film "Gone Girl."


October 3, 2014

Guest: Jeff Guinn

DAVID BIANCULLI, HOST: This is FRESH AIR. I'm David Bianculli sitting in for Terry Gross.


THE BEATLES: (Singing) Helter skelter. Helter skelter. Helter skelter. Yeah.

BIANCULLI: Lots of stoned listeners read all kinds of messages into the Beatles' "White Album," but nothing compares to the album's impact on Charles Manson. He heard it as a message directed especially to him and his followers, who were known as the family. The message was that an apocalyptic race war was soon to begin, in which blacks would rise up against their white oppressors and enslave them. This battle would be set off by an event called Helter Skelter. Manson planned on leading his followers into the desert, where they would remain in hiding until the chaos ended.

That's just one example of Manson's bizarre thinking. Many more examples are in a new biography by today's guest, Jeff Guinn. Among many people to whom Guinn spoke are Manson's sister and cousin who had never before given interviews, a former prison cellmate and two of his former followers, who are now in prison serving time for murder. Manson and his followers were responsible for nine killings, including the murder of Roman Polanski's pregnant wife, Sharon Tate.

Guinn's book called "Manson: The Life And Times Of Charles Manson" is now out in paperback. Terry spoke with Jeff Guinn last year.



Jeff Guinn, welcome to FRESH AIR. So for our listeners who may be too young to remember the Charles Manson story, or for listeners who have simply forgotten the details, just refresh our memories about why Charles Manson is so infamous.

JEFF GUINN: In the late 1960s, Charles Manson put together a family of followers who were either emotionally broken or drug-addled enough to buy into him as the second coming of Jesus Christ and themselves as the instigators of an apocalyptic race war.

On August 9th and 10th, 1969, the Family murdered seven people in horrific ways, and two others died at their hands before he was arrested. Helter Skelter is probably the most famous criminal trial in America because of that.

GROSS: And that was his trial.


GROSS: One of the things so interesting about Charles Manson in the '60s is that he's drawing on all these things that are the opposite of what he was. He's drawing on all these '60s countercultural ideals of, you know, open sexuality, living together in groups, forming families that aren't your own family.

And he's using it to create himself into a demonic cult leader. Is that what interested you about connecting him to that period?

GUINN: The most fascinating thing about Manson is that he certainly did what you describe in the 1960s, but by then he had already been doing the very same thing in the 1940s, in the 1950s. He was a lifelong sociopath who would take the best, most interesting things of cutting-edge culture and turn them to his own devices.

For instance in prison in the early 1950s, he got the basis of the street rap he would use later in Haight-Ashbury by cribbing lines, word for word, from chapter seven of Dale Carnegie's "How To Win Friends and Influence People."

GROSS: Which is an incredibly mainstream book.

GUINN: Well, it was at the time, I think, one of the most popular books in America. Dale Carnegie permeated every part of our culture. But it's Charlie Manson, this uneducated hick from West Virginia, who figures out ways to use Dale Carnegie precepts in the most horrible ways imaginable.

GROSS: Give us an example.

GUINN: I interviewed Leslie Van Houten and Patricia Krenwinkel, two of the convicted Tate-LaBianca murderers, in their women's prison in Corona, California. And when I came to see them - and I interviewed them separately - I asked right away what could Charles Manson possibly have said to you, when you first met him, that made you think this is an interesting man who seems to understand me; I want to talk more to him, I want to get close to him?

And they would say, well, Charlie said this, and he said this, and he said this, word for word from "How to Win Friends and Influence People." I got a copy of the textbook that Manson used in prison, and he cribbed those lines directly from it. So...

GROSS: What are some of the lines?

GUINN: He said - one of his philosophies was always make the other person think that the idea is his or her own. That's straight out of chapter seven. And Leslie Van Houten talked about how when she first meets Manson, he starts talking to her about how wonderfully intelligent she is, and she understands the Bible, and she's got all these great skills. She was a Kelly girl. And Manson was thrilled that she knew shorthand because he liked to make up song lyrics on the spot, and then he'd forget them.

So her first assignment was to follow him around with a notebook and in shorthand scribble down all the song lyrics he was improvising. But he intrigued her working straight from Chapter seven. With some of the men that he recruited, Carnegie wrote that the things that interest people most are the sex drive and the urge to be famous. And Manson promised the men who followed him all the sex they wanted, and if they stuck with him, they were going to not only be famous, they would rule the world after the apocalyptic race war he called Helter Skelter. So he's tying in these ideas from the 1940s with the cultural events of the 1960s.

GROSS: And he also included into his approach to manipulating people, something he learned from pimp philosophy, which is make the woman love you and fear you. He knew pimps in prison. Did he ever work as one himself?

GUINN: Oh, that was originally his plan for his life's work.

GROSS: To be a pimp?

GUINN: When he first goes to prison for car theft, he thinks this is a great opportunity to study at the feet of some of the great pimps, who for whatever reason or another, find themselves in prison with Charlie. And they teach him about separating women from their families and loved ones, beating them enough to scare them but being loving enough to make them feel valued, cut them off from every type of communication except your own.

And he just knew, instinctively sometimes, how to find a woman's weakness, whether it was a bad body image, whether she had serious issues with her father. He could exploit and would exploit anything like that.

GROSS: And he knew how to find vulnerable women. Like when he got - after his years in reform school and then prison, when he gets out, he goes to the Haight-Ashbury, and he basically looks for teenage runaways who were already in a very lost and vulnerable position.

GUINN: And this is what I mean again by how the threads of history come together to make something possible. Charlie Manson is paroled from prison in California. Now, if he's in Nebraska, let's say, and he gets out of prison, and he goes to live in Omaha, if he tried to pull this shtick with the daughters of the farmers of Nebraska they'd have stuck him on a pitchfork and left him in a field as a scarecrow.

But Haight-Ashbury is the place where as many as 300 teenage waifs a day are drifting in.

GROSS: This is 1967.

GUINN: Right. And Haight-Ashbury is overflowing with children who don't know where they're going, what they're going to do, what they're going to eat next, but they've come in search of some guru to be able to tell them what to do and make their lives better. And that's who Manson preys on.

GROSS: The Beatles were so important in his mind, and when "The White Album" came out - what year was "The White Album," the Beatles' White Album?

GUINN: 1968.

GROSS: Thank you. He saw that as having all kinds of secret messages, including secret messages to him. What did he read into "The White Album" and particularly to the track "Helter Skelter"?

GUINN: Actually what Manson did with "The White Album" was, just as he used the Book of Revelation to brainwash his followers, he would use the Beatles' music for the same reason. He didn't allow them to listen to much outside music. It was either the Beatles' albums or Charlie singing his own songs. And he also had a soft spot for Steppenwolf 's song "Born To Be Wild," for all your listeners who are old enough to remember it.

What Manson did over the winter of 1968 and the early months of 1969, was have his followers listen to "The White Album" over and over again and ask them to interpret for him what the songs were saying. And the songs in particular he wanted them to listen to were Helter Skelter, a song called "Piggies," another song called "Blackbird." And they had all these different wild guesses, but whenever someone would say, well, I think "Blackbird" is maybe about the black people rising up in America, Charlie would say, that's the most wonderful insight, I never thought of that, you're brilliant, when of course that's what he wanted someone to say all along.

And with "Helter Skelter," he claimed that this was The Beatles predicting an imminent race war, that blacks had been held down in history for so long, and now they were going to rise up. And when they did, they would massacre the white population. Charlie had been afraid of armed blacks ever since he ran into the Black Muslims in prison and the Black Panthers when he got out. He had a real fear of armed black men and believed they were coming for him anytime, if not for the rest of the world.

So he's saying that we're going to have this apocalyptic race war. When it breaks out, our Family will go out into Death Valley, where as the Bible has said, there is a bottomless pit with a great city underneath. We're going to go down in that pit, and we're going to wait out the war. And when the war is over and the blacks have won, because they're intellectually inferior, they won't be able to rule themselves. So they're going to have to turn to Manson and the Family to rule the world. And it says, I think, how indoctrinated his followers were, that most of them bought into at least part of the story.

GROSS: So when you talked to Leslie Van Houten and Patricia Krenwinkel, who were both followers of Manson, what did they tell you about how they saw his vision of Helter Skelter?

GUINN: They thought, as the rest of the Family did, that at this point Manson knew everything; that if he predicted this was happening, it was going to happen. Patricia Krenwinkel, more than Leslie Van Houten, was also physically afraid of Manson. One of the things he would do to the women who were his followers, to make them prove they were loyal, is he would have them stand against a tree and he would throw knives into the tree trunk over their heads. If they flinched, that meant they didn't really believe in him and therefore weren't worthy. He would hit the women, yank their hair. So Patricia said, more than anything else, she went along with him because of fear. Leslie Van Houten said she liked the drugs very much, and Charlie had promised that while they were in the underground city waiting out Helter Skelter, that they could change their bodies at will to become whatever they wanted.

And Leslie at this point in life thought it would be great to be an elf with wings. And after they were arrested and were in cells awaiting their indictments, she actually was afraid because she thought the wings were growing on her back, and they were growing out too soon. So that shows the kind of confusion that he had carefully crafted in his followers.

GROSS: And that kind of confusion could really be helped along, really encouraged, by hallucinogenic drugs. If you're taking hallucinogenics under the guidance of somebody who's crazy, you're being exposed to some really scary and - you'd be very impressionable in a way that you might not otherwise be. Bad trips can be very contagious in that respect.

So what did they tell you, what did the two Manson followers who you interviewed, tell you about what LSD sessions were like with Manson?

GUINN: Not only the two of them, but some other people who participated described these sessions. Manson would hand out the LSD and take a much smaller dose than anybody else. Then everyone else except Charlie was required to sit in a chair while Charlie sang or preached.

Quite often Manson would act out himself being crucified in front of them to strengthen the belief that he was Jesus coming in. If someone in the middle of a trip took a bad turn and started to make noise or move around, Manson would be furious, and he was pretty likely to hit 'em with something.

He actually - people said that a couple times he actually took a chair and smashed it into somebody's back and kept hitting them until they would sit quietly again. Again, the LSD trips were all part of Manson's overall plan. I mean, he had these people isolated all the time. There's a reason he picked isolated Spahn Ranch. There's a reason he wanted to take them out to Death Valley. He didn't want them being influenced by anyone other than himself.

BIANCULLI: Author Jeff Guinn speaking with Terry Gross in 2013. His book, "Manson: The Life And Times Of Charles Manson" is now out in paperback. More after a break. This is FRESH AIR.


BIANCULLI: This is FRESH AIR. Let's get back to Terry's interview from 2013 with author Jeff Guinn. His book "Manson: The Life And Times Of Charles Manson" is now out in paperback.


GROSS: Let's talk a little bit about music in Manson's life. He wanted to be Jesus or a rock star, or some combination of both. And he must've thought he was good, that he really had talent. And what he wanted to do was meet, like, famous rock stars or other famous people in the music industry and parlay that into a record contract so that he could find his audience and reach the fame he knew he was destined to have. And he was pretty successful at becoming friends with Dennis Wilson, the drummer of, you know, in the Beach Boys. How did he get to know Dennis Wilson?

GUINN: Well, Charlie's music roots actually go all the way back to his childhood, when he was the orneriest, most disagreeable little boy in McMechen, West Virginia. And the one good trait he had was that he had a nice singing voice. And when he would be forced to go to church by his grandma, at least when the time came to sing hymns, Charlie would be outstanding. And later on, he fell in love with the music of Frankie Laine.

GROSS: That amazed me in your book.


GROSS: It's, like, made me wonder, did Frankie Laine ever know that? Like, he liked Perry Como.

GUINN: Mm-hmm.

GROSS: He liked Frank - like, Frankie Laine was his hero when he was young.

GUINN: Right. Do not forsake me, oh, my darling. Charlie liked to sing that a lot.

GROSS: Oh, I wasn't thinking about that. Right. The theme from "High Noon."

GUINN: Right. But when Charlie's in prison, and he's in the workshop in 1964, 1965, suddenly, every other song on the radio was by this band called the Beatles. What got Charlie was not just the music, but the effect The Beatles had on everybody. Suddenly, you know, everybody's talking about them. Everybody's looking up to them, and Charlie wanted some of that for himself. So he had a guitar, and for the first time, he started writing songs. And he was positive when he got out of jail, if he could just get somebody powerful in the record business to hear him play his songs, he would get a record deal right away, would sell millions of records and become more famous than the Beatles.

So, when he moved his family to L.A. from Haight-Ashbury, he sent his women out to troll for rock stars. And it was a very heady time, when everybody was having sex with everybody else and sharing drugs. And it was just a matter of time until a couple of the Family women ran into Dennis Wilson, who invited them back to his palatial mansion off Sunset Boulevard.

He told them he wanted them to come with him to have some milk and cookies. And he actually meant it. He gave them cookies and raw milk. They didn't know who he was, because the Beach Boys', you know, sort of sunny, happy music was not the kind of music that Charlie allowed his followers to hear.

But they get back to Spahn Ranch, and Manson says, well, you know, did you find anybody? Did you find anybody? They said, well, yeah. You know, this guy picked us up. He said he was the drummer in some band you probably never heard of. They're called the Beach Boys?

And the next thing the women knew, Manson was insisting they bring him and the whole family back to Wilson's house. Wilson gets back from a recording session that night, and there's Charlie and the Family inviting him into his own house. But they had The Beatles on the record player. There were plenty of drugs, and most of the girls were naked, and Dennis liked that a lot.

And Manson and the Family members pretty much moved in for a while. Wilson listened to Charlie's songs, and Dennis was a nice guy. The Beach Boys had a label called Brother Records, and Dennis thought, well, maybe they'd record Charlie. But the rest of the Beach Boys thought he was a talentless bum, and so that didn't work out.

Manson moved on a little bit. Neil Young was impressed enough with Manson's music - his improvisations - to suggest that his label give Charlie a listen. But they weren't interested. John Phillips of the Mamas and the Papas passed. Rudy Altobelli, who was an agent for a lot of music stars, including Buffy St. Marie, didn't think Manson had anything special to offer.

So Manson set his sights on the one guy in L.A. who, if he liked Manson's music, Manson had a record deal right away. And that guy's name was Terry Melcher, the son of actress Doris Day and the boy wonder producer of rock and roll hits in Los Angeles. And Manson became obsessed with impressing Terry Melcher.

GROSS: Terry Melcher was producing The Byrds at the time.

GUINN: The Byrds. And he also - Melcher had this ability to sort of pick obscure performers and elevate them. Like, he found a garage band, dressed them up in Revolutionary War stuff, called them Paul Revere and the Raiders. And over the course, I guess, of three or four years at Columbia, Terry Melcher ends up producing about 80 hit singles.

So if he had thought Manson had talent, Manson would've gotten signed by Columbia Records. But when Manson auditioned for Melcher out at Spahn Ranch, Melcher's private reaction was this guy is nothing more or less than 100,000 other longhairs trying to pretend to be the Beatles. He has no sales potential. And he told Charlie in the politest way, you know, you're interesting, but I just wouldn't know what to do with you.

And when that happened, Manson's dream of becoming a rock star was essentially over, and that meant he had failed in front of his followers, who thought he couldn't fail. So he had to come up with something that would be audacious enough to bind them to him. And so that was one part - not all of it, but one part - of the reason for the Tate-LaBianca murders.

BIANCULLI: Jeff Guinn, speaking with Terry Gross in 2013. His book "Manson: The Life And Times Of Charles Manson" is now out in paperback. We'll continue their conversation in the second half of the show. I'm David Bianculli and this is FRESH AIR.


BIANCULLI: Coming up, how Charles Manson managed to get one of his own songs on the Beach Boys album "20/20," the album we're hearing now, as we continue our interview with Jeff Guinn about his Manson biography. Also, film critic David Edelstein reviews "Gone Girl," the new thriller starring Benn Affleck. And I'll preview the opening episodes of season four of Showtime's "Homeland."


BEACH BOYS: (Singing) I can hear music whenever you're near. Loving you, it keeps me satisfied and I can't explain, oh no, the way I'm feeling inside. You look at me, we kiss and then I close my eyes and here it comes again. I can hear music. I can hear music. The sound of the city baby, seems to disappear. I can hear music. Sweet, sweet music whenever you touch me, baby, whenever you're near.

BIANCULLI: This is FRESH AIR. I'm TV critic David Bianculli in for Terry Gross, back with more of Terry's 2013 interview with Jeff Guinn, author of a new biography of Charles Manson. It's now out in paperback. Manson was the leader of a cult group known as the Family that was responsible for an infamous series of murders including that of Sharon Tate, the pregnant wife of film director Roman Polanski. In the first part of the interview, Guinn was talking about Charles Manson's deranged dream of becoming a rock star and becoming as famous as The Beatles. For a while, Manson was friends with Brian Wilson of the Beach Boys. This was a chapter in Manson's life shortly before the murders of Sharon Tate and several others.


GROSS: Before we get to those murders, I want our listeners to hear some of Charles Manson's music. He wrote a song called "Cease To Exist," you know, he hoped would be recorded. And Dennis Wilson was, you know, actually recorded it, got it recorded on the Beach Boys' album "20/20," which was released, I think, in '69?

GUINN: Maybe '68.

GROSS: Maybe '68. Yeah.

GUINN: Late '68.

GROSS: OK. OK. So the lyric, the way Charles Manson sings it, includes the lines, pretty girl, cease to exist. Just come and say you love me. Give up your world and be with me. Submission is a gift. Give it to your brother.

And it's, like, whoa. That's almost like his philosophy. Like, girl, cease to exist? Give up your world and be with me? Submission is a gift?

GUINN: Very much so. And that was the reason Manson was furious with Wilson, not just for claiming complete authorship of the song himself...

GROSS: Yes. If you look on "20/20," it just has, you know, it's just credited to Dennis Wilson. There's no Charles Manson credit.

GUINN: But what really hacked Manson off was the fact that Wilson had the nerve to change Charlie's lyrics. He had always told Wilson, you can change my music any way you want to, but you can't change the lyrics. Because if Charlie said it, it must be true. And, as you said, the whole idea cease to exist is - that's Charlie throwing out his philosophy of life to any young woman listener. But Wilson changed all that around.

GROSS: But the line cease to exist is still in the Beach Boys' version, isn't it, even though that's no longer the title?

GUINN: Right.

GROSS: The title's "Never Learn Not To Love"?

GUINN: Right. But Wilson changed the tone of the song. And he might be addressing anyone, and not just a girl that he wanted to get - come submit to him. And Manson hated that.

GROSS: What I'd like to do is play the Manson version back to back with the Beach Boys version so our listeners can hear both of them. Any comments before we do that?

GUINN: (Laughing) I think you're going to see that Charles Manson actually was not quite the gifted musician he believed himself to be.

GROSS: I'm with you on that. This is, it's really not... (Laughing) It's not a good recording. OK. So here's Charles Manson doing a song "Cease To Exist," and then the Beach Boys doing a version that was titled "Never Learn Not To Love."


CHARLES MANSON: (Singing) Cease to exist. Just come and say you love me. Give up your world, come on, you can't be. I'm your kind, oh, your kind, and I can see. You walk on, walk on. I love you, pretty girl. My life is yours...


BEACH BOYS: (Singing) I'm your kind. I'm your kind, and I see. Never had a lesson I ever learned. I never know, I could never learn not to love you. Come in, now closer. Come in closer, closer, closer, ah. Submission is a gift given to another.

GROSS: So that was Charles Manson singing his song "Cease To Exist." And then we heard the version that the Beach Boys recorded, but it was under a different title, called "Never Learn Not To Love." And that was on their album "20/20." And my guest, Jeff Guinn, is the author of a new book about Charles Manson, called "Manson."

So, you were telling us that Manson really wanted to get a recording contract, but when everybody turned him down - including Terry Melcher, a very successful producer, who's also the son of Doris Day - he realized at some point he had to give up on his dream and continue to impress his followers with something else. So how does that lead to murder?

GUINN: Gurus can't be seen to fail by their followers. That's when the followers start to drift away. And some of Manson's followers were leaving him, some of his long-term people that he counted on and depended on. So he needs to do something spectacular. And here's where the other threads come in. Los Angeles is a hotbed of racial tension, maybe the worst in all major American cities in that year, in that hot summer. Watts had been just a few years before, and all across America, there's race riots. It's a terrible, tense time. And that permeates through the city, and Manson sees a way to use that.

At the same time, a drug deal has gone wrong, and Charlie has shot a man he believes to be a Black Panther, who was owed money by the Family for some drugs. And Charlie expects that the Black Panthers are going to come storming onto Spahn Ranch any time and attack. So there's that pressure on his followers.

And finally, there's a murder, a music teacher named Gary Hinman. The Family believes that Hinman has reneged on a drug deal with them. Bobby Beausoleil, a friend of Manson's but not a member of the Family, and a couple of the Manson women go down and torture Hinman. They think he's got money. He swears he doesn't. Manson comes in the middle of the night with his sword, cuts off part of Hinman's ear, leaves and later tells Beausoleil you know what to do, meaning kill him and try to make it look like the Black Panthers did it.

Beausoleil is arrested for Hinman's murder shortly afterward. He's driving a car stolen from Hinman, and he's got the bloody knife he used to kill Hinman in the wheel boot. Manson is worried that Beausoleil is going to flip on him, turn him in to the police. He can't have that happen, either.

So here, these things are coming together, and Manson helps the Family think, you know what? If there were copycat murders with signs again that black militants had done it, then the cops - because Bobby's in jail - would figure Bobby hadn't done it, and they'll have to let him go. Manson thinks that they need to kill famous rich people to get the kind of attention he wants. And if they can make it look like black militants did it, he tells everybody this will start Helter Skelter. This will make the whites mad, the blacks retaliate. We'll be in the desert. This is the beginning of the time that we're going to become masters of the world.

So they have to pick a place to go, and the reason they pick the house on Cielo Drive where Terry Melcher once lived is not because they think Melcher still lives there. They know he moved. But they also feel that only somebody really rich and famous could afford to live in that spectacular house at the top of a hill.

And Tex Watson, who Manson sends out that night with three of the women - Linda Kasabian, Susan Atkins and Patricia Krenwinkel - knows how to get to that house in the middle of the night, because they visited it before. So they picked this house not because they think Terry Melcher lives there, not because they know Sharon Tate is there, but because they know how to get there. It's location that decides the fate of five people that night.

GROSS: And Sharon Tate was the pregnant wife of the film director Roman Polanski. And she and four other people were murdered by Manson people. How did he try to pin the murders on the Black Panthers?

GUINN: He believed that if you left Black Panther signs, and they tried at the Hinman house to leave a bloody paw print on the wall - they thought the Black Panthers referred to the cops as pigs, which they did. But, of course, a lot of the young white revolutionaries did the same thing. So that's why they wrote the word pig in Sharon Tate's blood on the door of Cielo Drive. They thought these would be the signs that would make the cops think it was the Black Panthers.

And, of course, nothing like that happened at all, which is why Manson, furious, on the morning of August 10, decided they would have to go out and do it again that night. This time, he was going to come along the whole way, to make sure it was done correctly.

GROSS: And that's when Rosemary and Leno LaBianca were murdered.

GUINN: And, again, it was not a case of Manson specifically picking individuals. He and a lot of the Family members had attended parties at a house next door to the LaBiancas'. And so, again, they knew how to get there at night. It was just the LaBiancas' misfortune that they were there then.

BIANCULLI: Author Jeff Guinn speaking with Terry Gross in 2013. His book "Manson: The Life And Times Of Charles Manson" is now out in paperback. More after a break. This is FRESH AIR.


BIANCULLI: This is FRESH AIR. Let's get back to Terry's interview from last year with author Jeff Guinn. His book "Manson: The Life And Times Of Charles Manson" is now out in paperback.


GROSS: You tried to interview Manson and wrote him, what, like, 40 requests. What kind of response did you get?

GUINN: Well, I didn't hear anything for a long time, and finally, he wrote me a letter. It was not a pleasant letter. He did not want me to write the book. But later, when I asked to use some of his prison art in the photo section of the book, he gave me his permission. At any rate, Manson has loved this. He has always wanted to be famous, and if instead of being famous he has to be notorious, he'll settle for that. And, again, I think if we can just understand who this man is, he'll lose something of the magic that people have somehow imbued him with over all these years since.

GROSS: What is the magic that he's been imbued with?

GUINN: Manson fed into the national paranoia at a unique time in our history. When I interviewed Tom Hayden for this book, he said he didn't think there'd ever been a period in American history like 1968, '69, when something momentous seemed to happen virtually every day, something unbelievably good or horrifyingly bad, everything from assassinations, race riots, a very unpopular war that was dividing the nation.

At the same time you've got this amazing creative explosion in movies, in music and literature. A man walks on the moon. The New York Mets win the World Series, which at that time, people would have believed was far less possible than a man walking on the moon.

Every day, something is happening, and we're reeling emotionally, and we were not yet used to horrific murders. There was something unique about these, an evil hippie guru sending his addled followers out. And now, of course, I think we've seen so many mass murders in the most horrible of ways, it's kind of like Charlie established himself as the first king of that particular crime and has held the title ever since. He's a terrible, terrible human being, but there's nothing mystic or magic about him.

GROSS: Are any of Charles Manson's followers in touch with you, and have you gotten any intimidating messages from any of them who maybe don't want to see the story told?

GUINN: Well, Manson very kindly shared my contact information with some of his current followers, and I've heard from quite a few of them. They're an interesting mix, and some of them are actually interesting folks. I thought that, you know, they wouldn't be, shall we say, exceptionally bright, but some of them are intelligent people who I think have just chosen the wrong person to admire.

GROSS: About how many followers of Manson's are still out there?

GUINN: They must number in the hundreds, and they're all over the country.

GROSS: Really? Oh. What qualifies as being a follower at this point? And it sounds more like a fan than a follower.

GUINN: Well, Manson doesn't really differentiate, but he communicates with lots of folks. He likes to stay in touch with people who are fairly worshipful of him.

GROSS: I would like to hear you describe why you think some people would choose to follow him now, when we know he's behind the murders of - eight?

GUINN: Nine.

GROSS: Nine, thank you. Like, now that we really know the story, why would somebody want to follow him?

GUINN: They don't accept that as facts. If Manson says I never killed anybody, that's all they want to hear. There are people in this world who are going to believe what they want to, and aren't going to let the facts get in the way.

GROSS: Jeff Guinn, thank you so much for talking with us.

GUINN: It's been a pleasure. Thank you.

BIANCULLI: Author Jeff Guinn, speaking with Terry Gross in 2013. His book "Manson: The Life and Times of Charles Manson" is now out in paperback.

DAVID BIANCULLI, HOST: Season four of the Showtime drama series "Homeland" begins Sunday. And it begins with a very significant change. Claire Danes is back as Carrie Mathison - the gifted but troubled CIA agent with a bipolar disorder. But her co-star for the first 3 seasons, Damian Lewis who played former POW and suspected traitor Nicholas Brody, is not. When we left "Homeland" at the end of what ultimately was a disappointing season, Brody and Carrie's dreams to escape politics and run off together had died, along with Brody who was hanged in Tehran by an angry mob as Carrie watched helplessly. But Carrie was carrying his unborn child. As season four of "Homeland" begins, her baby is still around, but Carrie has found ways - most of the time - to keep an emotional and physical distance. She's pulled the same trick with her old CIA boss Saul Berenson played by Mandy Patinkin. He's now working for a private security firm. They haven't spoken in months. Yet when Saul shows up attending a Pentagon briefing and unable to keep his thoughts to himself, it's clear that "Homeland"- this many years in - is just like Saul. It still has things to say and ideas to explore even if they're not always comfortable to absorb.


MANDY PATINKIN: (As Berenson) Actually, I have another thing I was going to mention - just a thought I want to throw out there.


PATINKIN: (As Berenson) If we'd known in 2001 we were staying in Afghanistan this long, I would've made some different choices.

ACTOR: (As character) Right.

PATINKIN: (As Berenson) Instead our planning cycles rarely look more than 12 months ahead. So it hasn't been a 14-year war we've been waging, but a one-year war waged 14 times. I think we're walking away with the job half done.

BIANCULLI: What made the first season of "Homeland" so distinctive and so compelling was that we had two equally strong characters on very different sides of the story. And we couldn't be sure for quite a while which one deserved our empathy and loyalty more. Season one of "Homeland," if it had ended with that assassination attempt and its aftermath, could've been a standalone, one season, mini-masterpiece of television. But even back when "Homeland" began, TV wasn't making self-contained one season dramas as it's since done so well with "Fargo" and "True Detective." So "Homeland" kept going and eventually last year lost its way and much of its urgency. But now it's back. The quickly developing central plot this season has Carrie overseeing a so-called surgical strike bombing of a site in Pakistan aimed at a highly-placed name on the government's kill list. But thanks to some bad intelligence, the site is a wedding party. And the result is an international embarrassment for the U.S. military. One young man survives the carnage. And his smart phone contains a video showing the wedding festivities at the very moment the bomb goes off. This makes "Homeland" once again the story of twin protagonists who divide our loyalties as we watch. There is the young survivor who has been given all the motivation to become a terrorist, but it may not be in his nature. And there's Carrie who takes her laser focus and trains it on discovering why things went wrong while alienating almost everyone around her along the way. Even while she's dealing with one of the few people she trusts, Peter Quinn, a black-ops assassin with a conscience played by Rupert Friend, Carrie has a way of compartmentalizing that makes her hard to reach.


CLAIRE DANES: (As Carrie Mathison) Can we sit for 10 minutes. You give me the lay of the land?

RUPERT FRIEND: (As Peter Quinn) Sure. The ambassador's out front with the locals on this, so she's pissed.

DANES: (As Carrie Mathison) Well, I can't say I blame her. Sandy's intel was good until now. What do you think happened?

FRIEND: (As Peter Quinn) No idea. Not even his own case officers know what he's up to half the time.

DANES: (As Carrie Mathison) Lone Wolf.

FRIEND: (As Peter Quinn) Leaves the embassy, odd hours, doesn't say where to.

DANES: (As Carrie Mathison) Girlfriend?

FRIEND: (As Peter Quinn) Maybe or maybe he's meeting the asset who's feeding him these opportune targets.

DANES: (As Carrie Mathison) So who is this asset of his?

FRIEND: (As Peter Quinn) Thought you knew.

DANES: (As Carrie Mathison) Nope.

FRIEND: (As Peter Quinn) Well, I have no clue either, so you'll have to ask him.

DANES: (As Carrie Mathison) Well, I will 'cause I'm the one dropping fire on all these people.

FRIEND: (As Peter Quinn) Yeah, well I know what that's like.

DANES: (As Carrie Mathison) Why?

FRIEND: (As Peter Quinn) Checking names off a kill list for a living.

DANES: (As Carrie Mathison) It's a job.

FRIEND: (As Peter Quinn) It doesn't bother you? What about when it goes wrong?

DANES: (As Carrie Mathison) It doesn't happen that often.

FRIEND: (As Peter Quinn) But it did this time.

BIANCULLI: I've previewed the first three episodes of the new season. And each of them includes a sequence so intense and so emotionally involving I leaned forward while watching them. This season four plot line doesn't paint Carrie as a good friend and certainly not as a good mother. But as a spy, when she follows her instincts, she's the best. And "Homeland," with an ultra-timely story about terrorism, could shape up again as one of TV's best, too. Coming up, film critic David Edelstein reviews "Gone Girl," the new movie starring Ben Affleck. This is FRESH AIR.

DAVID BIANCULLI, HOST: This is FRESH AIR. The film adaptation of Gillian Flynn's best-selling mystery novel, "Gone Girl" arrives in movie theaters today. It's directed by David Fincher, best known for "The Social Network" and "The Girl With The Dragon Tattoo." And it stars Ben Affleck, Rosamund Pike and in smaller roles, Neil Patrick Harris and Tyler Perry. Film critic David Edelstein has this review.

DAVID EDELSTEIN, BYLINE: What can I tell you about "Gone Girl" without dropping a dreaded spoiler? It's a film, you know that, and a long one, almost two and half hours, though they go by quickly. It's based on a best-selling mystery by Gillian Flynn, that divided readers and divided me. I loved the audacity of the plotting, without being sold on the pathology of one of the characters.

The movie, directed by David Fincher, from a screenplay by Flynn is sensationally effective. It's even more fun than the book. It's made like a classic noir, evenly paced with an elegance that in context is deeply perverse. Ben Affleck plays Nick Dunne, an ex-magazine writer who's about to celebrate his fifth anniversary of marriage to his wife, Amy. But since that afternoon, in the Missouri bar he runs with his twin sister, looking glum and antsy. He arrives at his suburban McMansion to find signs of a struggle and no Amy. So far, so straightforward, but detectives linger over the incongruities of the scene. Did Nick murder Amy and make it look like a kidnapping? He's evasive about something.

A clue might come from the stunning prologue, a shot of the back of a woman's head on a pillow, her golden tresses aglow. Nick narrates, stroking her hair. He says, the only way to know what's in a person's mind would be to shatter her skull. Then the woman turns to face the camera. It's Amy, played by Rosamund Pike. Her eyes open, and she stares into ours, the look is teasingly ambiguous. "Gone Girl" weaves Nick's dissent into public infamy, with excerpts from a diary Amy kept before she disappeared read aloud by the gone girl herself. First it's idyllic. The courtship begins at a New York cocktail party.


BEN AFFLECK: (As Nick Dunne) Amy, who are you?

ROSAMUND PIKE: (As Amy Elliot-Dunne) A - I'm an award-winning Scrimshawer. B - I'm a moderately influential warlord. C - I write personality quizzes for magazines.

AFFLECK: (As Nick Dunne) OK. Well, your hands are far too delicate for real Scrimshaw work, and I happen to be a charter subscriber to Middle East Warlord Weekly, so I'd recognize you. I'm going to go with C.

PIKE: (As Amy Elliot-Dunne) And you? Who are you?

AFFLECK: (As Nick Dunne) I'm the guy to save you from all this awesomeness.

EDELSTEIN: They are a beautiful couple. Affleck has his beefy handsomeness. Pike is like a sleek mannequin. Director Fincher's frames are gorgeous, but it's clear from "Gone Girl" and his other films like "Se7en" and "The Social Network" that he has no faith in appearances. His is a world of masks, misrepresentations - surfaces lie. Amy's character in particular understands this. She grew up the model for the heroine of her parents children's books, the character called Amazing Amy. But she can't measure up to her literary counterpart. She knows there is a gulf between how her parents represented her and what she really is.

Rosamund Pike is fascinating to watch, but it's Affleck who carries the movie. I've never much cottoned to him as an actor. I think something in him never fully commits, but that's what Fincher hones in on. Affleck's Nick doesn't mourn convincingly or look remotely honest, even when telling the truth. In one scene, his hotshot lawyer, played by Tyler Perry, rehearses him for a TV appearance and pelts him with candy when he sounds like he's lying. He gets pelted a lot. Carrie Coon is excellent as Nick's sister and Kim Dickens, delightfully acidic as a detective. There's also a satisfyingly scathing turn by Missi Pyle as a character with a strong resemblance to CNN's Nancy Grace, a ghoulish specialist in whipping up viewers' ire.

And there I would leave this phenomenally gripping film, except without revealing too much. There are instances in "Gone Girl" of trumped-up sexual assaults, and the timing is particularly bad given the present heightened awareness of real crimes against women, but this of course is a fictional story, written by a woman. Maybe we should view it as a profoundly cynical portrait of all sides of all relationships.

BIANCULLI: David Edelstein is film critic for New York magazine.

Transcripts are created on a rush deadline, and accuracy and availability may vary. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Please be aware that the authoritative record of Fresh Air interviews and reviews are the audio recordings of each segment.

You May Also like

Did you know you can create a shareable playlist?


Recently on Fresh Air Available to Play on NPR


Daughter of Warhol star looks back on a bohemian childhood in the Chelsea Hotel

Alexandra Auder's mother, Viva, was one of Andy Warhol's muses. Growing up in Warhol's orbit meant Auder's childhood was an unusual one. For several years, Viva, Auder and Auder's younger half-sister, Gaby Hoffmann, lived in the Chelsea Hotel in Manhattan. It was was famous for having been home to Leonard Cohen, Dylan Thomas, Virgil Thomson, and Bob Dylan, among others.


This fake 'Jury Duty' really put James Marsden's improv chops on trial

In the series Jury Duty, a solar contractor named Ronald Gladden has agreed to participate in what he believes is a documentary about the experience of being a juror--but what Ronald doesn't know is that the whole thing is fake.


This Romanian film about immigration and vanishing jobs hits close to home

R.M.N. is based on an actual 2020 event in Ditrău, Romania, where 1,800 villagers voted to expel three Sri Lankans who worked at their local bakery.

There are more than 22,000 Fresh Air segments.

Let us help you find exactly what you want to hear.
Just play me something
Your Queue

Would you like to make a playlist based on your queue?

Generate & Share View/Edit Your Queue